The promises came down to nothing

Development partners express hesitation during July movement

Eiahia Nakib

Photo: Bonik Barta

The student movement that started with demands for quota reform rapidly progressed towards a popular uprising in July. At one point, the Awami League government was compelled to relinquish power, which had been held for 16 years. Throughout this movement, Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina's government faced national and international pressure from the outset. Doubts arose among countries and organizations that were considered Bangladesh's leading development partners. This also affected the promises of foreign aid to Bangladesh in July. During that month, Bangladesh did not receive any new commitments for funding from foreign donors.

Analysts say that foreigners only invest if the situation in the destination country is stable. In July, a sense of uncertainty was created around the movement in the country. Development partners focused on whether the government could manage the situation. Moreover, due to the deteriorating security and political framework, there was no conducive environment for ongoing discussions in July. At the same time, the AL government was primarily occupied with suppressing the movement rather than engaging in talks. However, with the fall of Sheikh Hasina's government and the formation of an interim government, Bangladesh emerged from that situation, creating an opportunity for a fresh perspective.

According to the latest data published by the Economic Relations Division (ERD), the Asian Development Bank (ADB) has become the most significant multilateral development partner in recent years. However, the ADB did not make any new investment commitments in July, and neither did the World Bank. Additionally, the Beijing-based Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB), a significant new source of funding for the infrastructure sector in recent years, did not provide any new investment commitments in July.

The same situation was observed with bilateral development partners. Bangladesh's most significant development partner, Japan, has consistently provided development assistance since independence. However, no funding commitments were received from Japan in July. The largest infrastructure project in the country's power sector, the Rooppur Nuclear Power Plant, is being constructed with Russian funding and technical assistance. The Sheikh Hasina government had strengthened relations with Russia despite various geopolitical alignments globally. Nonetheless, no new funding commitments were received from Moscow in July.

Professor Dr. Mustafizur Rahman, Distinguished Fellow of Center for Policy Dialogue (CPD), believes that discussions on funding with foreign development partners could not be conducted at that time due to the ongoing large-scale movement. In this context, he told the Bonik Barta, "The country was uncertain. Therefore, development partners did not make new commitments. Now, priorities are being redefined, and development partners are showing interest. A new opportunity for discussions has emerged."

Bangladesh received no new funding commitments from its closest neighbors, India and China, for the fiscal year 2023-24. Despite multiple visits to India by Sheikh Hasina during her third term in office, the country did not find support during the crisis. Although there was frequent talk of a new chapter in relations between the two countries, the anticipated support did not materialize. Similarly, despite high expectations, Sheikh Hasina returned almost empty-handed from her visit to China. Analysts at the time commented that this situation arose primarily due to the failure to balance the interests of China and India regarding the Teesta project funding.

In the current circumstances, multinational institutions and bilateral countries are announcing their intention to work with the new government. Ambassadors from China and India are actively engaging, and ADB and World Bank representatives are also in discussions. However, analysts believe the government is unlikely to decide on sensitive projects like the Teesta project. Dr. Selim Raihan, Executive Director of the private research organization South Asian Network on Economic Modeling (SANEM), told Bonik Barta, "Many will come to discuss various issues. However, it seems unlikely that the government will move forward on sensitive projects like the Teesta at this stage. Decisions will need to be made carefully and thoughtfully. The government has requested several billion dollars in support from the World Bank and ADB. Receiving this support would be positive for the country."

In response to whether new funding sources or new relationships might emerge, a professor from the Department of Economics at Dhaka University said, "It is advisable to seek higher funding at lower interest rates from BRICS or AIIB. This would diversify the country's loan portfolio."

The full implementation of past loan commitments from China and India has not yet been achieved. Despite several agreements and promises with the two countries, Dhaka is complaining about slow progress in implementation and disbursement of funds.

In 2016, Chinese President Xi Jinping visited Bangladesh. A Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) titled "Strengthening and Production Capacity Cooperation" was signed at that time. Under this agreement, Xi Jinping promised approximately 25 billion dollars in financial assistance across various sectors. The MoU outlined the implementation of 27 projects in Bangladesh with Chinese loans. Although work on 10 of these projects eventually began, most have not yet been completed.

India has committed to providing 7.3 billion dollars to Bangladesh under three Lines of Credit (LoCs). The first LoC agreement between the two countries was signed in 2010, followed by two additional LoC agreements in 2016 and 2017. According to ERD sources, under these agreements, less than 1.5 billion dollars has been disbursed so far. Additionally, the disbursement under the second and third agreements has been slow, and there are complexities regarding the terms of the agreements. Dhaka has had to negotiate several times over the terms of these agreements. Although there were discussions about relaxing the terms during Sheikh Hasina's last visit, no final announcement regarding changes has been made.

Dr. Amena Mohsin, a former professor in the Department of International Relations at Dhaka University, told Bonik Barta, "Foreigners were observing the situation at that time. Amid the uncertainty, they did not invest their taxpayers' money. Now, efforts can be made to increase foreign funding in various sectors, including tourism. However, to boost foreign investment or funding, corruption in the country must be reduced to a minimal level. We also need to focus on cultural soft power."

When asked about the overall situation, a senior ERD official, speaking on anonymity, told Bonik Barta, "We have already discussed budget support with the ADB, the World Bank, and Korea. We hope to receive 1.5 billion dollars solely for budget support from them. Funding for ongoing and new projects is also available and will continue."

 

এই বিভাগের আরও খবর

আরও পড়ুন